Summary of God Sees the Truth But Waits
“God Sees the Truth, But Waits” is a poignant short story written by the famous Russian author Leo Tolstoy. It explores themes of fate, forgiveness, and divine justice, presenting a deep moral lesson through its simple yet impactful narrative.
The story begins in the small town of Vladimir, where Ivan Dmitrich Aksionov lives with his family. Aksionov is a well-liked and prosperous merchant known for his jovial nature and upright character. One day, he decides to travel to the Nizhny Fair to sell his goods. Despite his wife’s ominous dream urging him to reconsider his journey, Aksionov dismisses her concerns and sets off on his trip.
During his journey, Aksionov meets another merchant and the two decide to rest at the same inn. The next morning, Aksionov continues his journey, but he is soon stopped by the police. They accuse him of murdering the merchant he had befriended the previous night. The police find a blood-stained knife in Aksionov’s bag, which he vehemently denies owning. Despite his protests of innocence, Aksionov is arrested and charged with murder and robbery.
Aksionov’s life is shattered. He is taken away from his family and sentenced to 26 years of hard labor in Siberia. Throughout his imprisonment, Aksionov endures immense suffering and despair. Initially, he is filled with anger and a desire for revenge, but over time, he turns to God for solace. He becomes deeply religious, reading the Bible and praying regularly, which earns him the respect of his fellow prisoners and even the prison authorities.
Years pass, and Aksionov’s once vibrant appearance fades. He becomes an old man, his hair and beard turning white, and his health deteriorates due to the harsh conditions in the labor camp. Despite his unjust imprisonment, Aksionov maintains his faith in God and gradually lets go of his bitterness.
One day, a new group of prisoners arrives, including Makar Semyonich, a man from Aksionov’s hometown. During a conversation, Aksionov overhears Makar boasting about his criminal exploits. Aksionov becomes suspicious and eventually realizes that Makar is the real murderer who framed him all those years ago.
One night, Aksionov catches Makar digging a tunnel to escape from the prison. Although he initially contemplates revenge, Aksionov decides against it and chooses not to report Makar to the authorities. This act of compassion confuses and deeply affects Makar. He later approaches Aksionov, confesses to the murder, and begs for forgiveness. Aksionov, with a heavy heart, forgives Makar, finding peace in his act of mercy.
Makar, moved by Aksionov’s forgiveness, decides to confess his crime to the authorities, hoping to exonerate Aksionov. He does so, and an investigation is launched. The authorities eventually find Makar’s confession credible, and Aksionov is declared innocent. However, the years of imprisonment have taken their toll on Aksionov’s health, and he dies shortly after his innocence is proven.
“God Sees the Truth, But Waits” is a profound story that underscores the themes of patience, forgiveness, and the ultimate triumph of truth. It illustrates how Aksionov’s faith and moral integrity help him endure his wrongful imprisonment and how divine justice, although delayed, ultimately prevails. The story serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of forgiveness and the belief that truth and righteousness will eventually come to light, even if it takes time.
1. Answer the following questions in a sentence or two each, based on your understanding of the story.
a) Why did Aksionov’s wife stop him from going to the fair?
Answer: Aksionov’s wife stopped him because she had a bad dream in which Aksionov returned from the fair with gray hair.
b) What is the importance of Aksionov’s wife’s dream?
Answer: The dream foreshadowed the misfortune that would befall Aksionov, suggesting that something terrible would happen to him if he went to the fair.
c) What made Aksionov leave the inn before dawn?
Answer: Aksionov was not in the habit of sleeping late. He wanted to travel while it was still cool and that’s why he left the inn before dawn.
d) What were the circumstances that led to Aksionov’s imprisonment?
Answer: Aksionov had spent the previous night with the merchant who had been murdered in the inn. When the police searched his travel bag, they found a blood-stained knife. They suspected that Aksionov was the murderer because the house was locked from inside, and no one else was there. Also, his pale face, broken voice and fearful look made him look guilty.
e) Why did Aksionov give up sending petitions?
Answer: Aksionov gave up sending petitions for his release because he lost hope and felt that only God could help him now.
f) Why didn’t Makar disclose that he had killed the merchant?
Answer: Makar didn’t disclose his crime initially because he did not want to be punished and go to prison.
g) Did Makar feel guilty when he heard Aksionov’s story?
Answer: Initially, when Makar heard Aksionov’s story, he did not feel guilty . But later on when Aksionov denied any knowledge of Makar’s escape plans to the prison authorities, he regretted his act and begged Aksionov to forgive him.
h) What made Aksionov think that Makar was the real murderer?
Answer: Aksionov suspected Makar was the real murderer when Makar showed knowledge about Aksionov and the murder that only the killer would know.
i) What was Aksionov’s realization by the end of the story?
Answer: By the end of the story, Aksionov realized that forgiveness and faith in God are more important than seeking revenge or justice through human means.
j) Why did Aksionov’s wife suspect him of involvement in the murder?
Answer: Aksionov’s wife suspected him because of the incriminating evidence (the blood-stained knife) and the fact that he used to drink and waste his time in the past.
2. Answer the following questions in three or four sentences each.
a) Did the police officer have sufficient evidence to convict Aksionov?
Answer: The police officer did not have sufficient evidence to conclusively convict Aksionov. The primary piece of evidence was the blood-stained knife found in Aksionov’s bag, which was circumstantial. There were no witnesses or direct proof linking Aksionov to the crime scene, making the evidence against him weak and based largely on suspicion.
b) What impact did the book “The Lives of Saints” have on Aksionov?
Answer: “The Lives of Saints” had a profound impact on Aksionov, providing him with spiritual solace and strength during his imprisonment. Reading the book helped Aksionov find peace and maintain his faith in God, allowing him to endure his long and unjust imprisonment with a sense of calm and forgiveness. It guided him to live a life of piety and acceptance despite his hardships.
c) Pick out the clues that convey that Makar Semyonich recognized Aksionov.
Answer: Makar Semyonich recognized Aksionov through several subtle clues. When Makar came to the prison and learnt the story of Aksionov’s wrongful imprisonment, he reacted in excitement and surprise and seemed delighted to meet him there, indicating that he had already met him before. Another indication that he recognized Aksionov was when he exclaimed that he had grown very old, as if he had seem him when he was young and now recognized him in his old age. When the other prisoners asked him where he had seen Aksionov before, he avoided answering the question – another sign that he knew about Aksionov but did not want to reveal the truth.
3. Answer the following questions in a paragraph in about 150 words each.
a) Compare and contrast the main characters, Aksionov and Makar Semyonich, in the story.
Answer: Aksionov and Makar Semyonich represent two contrasting aspects of human nature. Aksionov is a kind-hearted, honest, and pious man who becomes a victim of circumstance. His innocence, coupled with his moral strength, is evident throughout his years of unjust imprisonment. He endures his suffering with patience and eventually forgives the man responsible for his misery. In contrast, Makar Semyonich is initially portrayed as a deceitful and morally corrupt individual who commits the crime and lets another man suffer for it. However, towards the end of the story, Makar experiences a transformation, feeling guilt and remorse for his actions. This change in Makar highlights the potential for redemption in everyone. While Aksionov’s character demonstrates resilience and forgiveness, Makar’s character shows that guilt and repentance can lead to moral redemption.
b) How did Aksionov react when his wife suspected him?
Answer: When Aksionov’s wife visited him in prison and expressed her doubts about his innocence, Aksionov was deeply hurt and pained. Her suspicion added to his misery as it implied a lack of faith from the person closest to him. Despite this, Aksionov did not react with anger or defensiveness. Instead, he felt a profound sense of despair and helplessness. Her doubts mirrored the unjust accusations from society, compounding his feeling of isolation. Nonetheless, he bore this with the same resignation and patience that characterized his entire response to his unjust imprisonment, showing his deep sense of acceptance and endurance in the face of immense suffering.
c) Describe the life of Aksionov in prison.
Answer: Aksionov’s life in prison was marked by suffering, reflection, and eventual spiritual enlightenment. Initially, he struggled with the injustice of his situation and the loss of his former life. Over time, Aksionov turned to religion for solace, finding peace in prayer and reading religious texts like “The Lives of Saints.” He became a model prisoner, respected by both inmates and guards for his piety, wisdom, and calm demeanor. Despite the harsh conditions and long years of confinement, Aksionov maintained a quiet dignity and grace, using his time to deepen his faith. His transformation into a spiritually enlightened individual helped him endure the hardships and injustices of prison life, ultimately leading him to forgive Makar Semyonich and accept his fate with equanimity.
d) Why did Aksionov decide not to reveal the truth about Makar Semyonich?
Answer: Aksionov decided not to reveal the truth about Makar Semyonich because he had reached a state of inner peace and spiritual enlightenment that transcended his desire for revenge. After years of unjust imprisonment, Aksionov had found solace in his faith and had come to terms with his fate. When Makar confessed his guilt, Aksionov realized that revealing the truth would only perpetuate the cycle of suffering and vengeance. Instead, he chose to forgive Makar, embodying the Christian ideals of mercy and forgiveness. Aksionov’s decision not to expose Makar was a testament to his moral strength and his belief in divine justice, trusting that God would ultimately judge and forgive.
e) Discuss the meaning and importance of the saying “God sees the truth but waits”.
Answer: The saying “God sees the truth but waits” reflects the belief that divine justice operates on a different timeline than human justice. It underscores the idea that while injustice and suffering may prevail in the short term, the ultimate truth and moral balance will be restored by a higher power in due course. In the context of the story, Aksionov suffers unjustly for a crime he did not commit, enduring years of hardship and wrongful imprisonment. Despite this, he maintains his faith and integrity, believing that God knows the truth of his innocence. The saying emphasizes patience, resilience, and faith in the face of adversity, suggesting that even when human systems fail, divine justice will eventually prevail. It highlights the moral that true justice, though delayed, is inevitable and serves to test and ultimately strengthen the character of those who endure suffering with grace and faith.
f) Forgiveness is the best form of revenge. Substantiate the statement with reference to the story.
Answer: In “God Sees the Truth, But Waits,” forgiveness emerges as a powerful theme that underscores the idea that true revenge lies not in retribution, but in the act of forgiveness. Aksionov, who is wrongfully imprisoned for a crime he did not commit, undergoes immense suffering and transformation. When he finally encounters the real murderer, Makar Semyonich, Aksionov is faced with a choice: to seek revenge or to forgive. By choosing to forgive Makar, Aksionov transcends the bitterness and hatred that could have consumed him. This act of forgiveness not only liberates Aksionov spiritually but also leads Makar to a profound sense of guilt and repentance. Thus, Aksionov’s forgiveness serves as a form of moral victory, demonstrating that letting go of anger and embracing forgiveness can be more powerful and redemptive than seeking revenge. This resolution highlights the strength and nobility in forgiveness, showing it as the ultimate form of triumph over wrongdoing.
4. Using the mind map given below, write a brief summary of the story in your own words.
Answer:
Ivan Dmitrich Aksionov, a successful merchant, lived with his wife and children. One day, he decided to travel to a fair. His wife had a bad dream and pleaded with him to stay and not go to the fair, but he went ahead anyway. On the way, he stopped at an inn and shared a room with another merchant. The following morning, he continued his journey, only to be arrested by the local police officer for the murder of the merchant he had shared a room with. Despite his pleas of innocence, Aksionov was convicted based on the blood-stained knife found in his bag and other circumstantial evidence.
Aksionov was sentenced to work in the mines of Siberia, where he grew old, losing hope and enduring great suffering. He frequently prayed to God and found solace in religious texts, particularly “The Lives of the Saints.” His pious and gentle behavior earned him the respect of fellow inmates and guards.
Years later, Aksionov encountered Makar Semyonich, a new prisoner, who eventually confessed to being the real murderer. Despite the opportunity to reveal the truth and gain his freedom, Aksionov chose not to accuse Makar. He had reached a state of spiritual peace and understood the futility of earthly justice. By forgiving Makar, Aksionov attained self-realization and inner peace. He died shortly after, content and reconciled with his fate.
Leave a Reply